AP World DBQ: Religious Toleration in Land-Based Empires

Finding primary sources is one of the most time-consuming parts of planning. More are digitized every year, but digging through them to find the right excerpts for a particular lesson is still tedious. As in grad school, though, the thrill of finding the source that makes all the pieces fit never gets old.

The College Board has released plenty of old DBQs, but there are still quite a few gaps in their coverage. I use primary sources in class almost every day, and the released sets don’t cover everything I want. Right now I’m wrapping up Units 3 and 4, which I teach as one combined unit. While looking for sources on the land-based empires I found more and more that were connected to the theme of religious toleration.

Ultimately, I landed on a source set that would ask students to assess different examples of religious toleration and whether they strengthened or weakened a ruler’s power. Thus my prompt: Evaluate the extent to which religious toleration strengthened the power of rulers in land-based empires from c. 1450 to c. 1750. The full DBQ, along with a student organizer are linked at the bottom of the post.


What “Toleration” Meant

Narsingh, court painter, illustration for the Akbarnama, the official history of Emperor Akbar’s reign, circa 1600–1605. World History Encyclopedia

The biggest misconception students bring to this question is the word itself. When they hear “toleration,” they think of religious freedom and equality. Almost no ruler in the period meant that, and policies of tolerance or intolerance were built around need and context.

In the land-based empires, toleration usually meant permission to exist under someone else’s faith. In the Islamic empires, Christians and Jews (and in Mughal India, Hindus) could worship, run their own community affairs, and often live by their own religious law. In return they accepted a lower status, paid a special tax, the jizya, and lived with rules about where they could build and how visible their faith could be. The primary sources I found illustrated how these communities lived in this second-class state. However, comparison with Europe makes things more complicated.

In the same era, Europe was settling religious questions with expulsions and wars. Spain expelled Jews in 1492, and the Ottomans welcomed many of them. The Peace of Augsburg in 1555 let each German prince choose his territory’s religion and left everyone else to conform or move. France granted Protestants toleration in 1598 and took it back in 1685. By those standards, an Ottoman or Mughal subject of a minority faith was often better off.

Toleration, when it occurred, was not exactly based on complete goodwill and rulers tolerated other faiths for practical reasons. The land-based empires of the early modern world stretched across lands that included many peoples. Rulers needed their loyalty, labor, taxes, and skills regardless of whether they shared the ruler’s religion. Akbar ended the jizya in 1564 and brought Hindu Rajput rulers into his government and army, which helped him hold an empire with a Hindu majority. The Qing patronized Tibetan Buddhism and kept European Jesuits at court as astronomers. In many of the examples we teach, toleration is less a value and more a tool or strategy for ruling.

Still, enforcing one faith was a tool too. The Safavids built a new state in Persia after 1501 by making Shia Islam its official religion, which gave their subjects a shared identity and set them sharply apart from the Sunni Ottomans next door. The Qing promoted Confucian orthodoxy and treated popular religious movements as a threat to order. Aurangzeb brought back the jizya in 1679, a century after Akbar abolished it, and the Mughal Empire reached its greatest size under his rule even as resistance to him grew.

How will students shape an answer to the DBQ question? Like most good DBQs, it will be some version of “it depends.” Toleration strengthened rulers when it bought them loyalty, skills, or revenue. Uniformity strengthened rulers when it built a shared identity against a rival. And in nearly every case, rulers tolerated only as much as served them.


The Documents

The Internet Archive has been the most useful database for finding good primary source excerpts. Countless 19th- and early 20th-century books have been digitized that hold primary source translations. For my own sanity though, I did not keep track of how much time it took.

Document 1: An invitation to the Ottoman Empire (c. 1456)

A few years after the Ottomans took Constantinople, a Jewish scholar named Isaac Zarfati wrote to the Jewish communities of Germany and Hungary urging them to move. His question to them was direct, “Is it not better for you to live under Moslems than under Christians?” In the Ottoman lands, he says, every man may live “at peace under his own vine and his own fig-tree.”

Document 2: A Christian at the shah’s court (1562)

In 1562 Anthony Jenkinson, an English merchant hoping to open trade with Persia, made his way to the shah’s court. In his retelling of his arrival in Persia, he states that he was made to wear the shah’s own shoes in order to be allowed to tread upon the ‘holy ground’ as a Gower, or unbeliever. Ultimately, he fails in his goal and is sent off.

There is a section earlier in the source, which I did not include in the excerpt, that helps us understand why Jenkinson did not get what he hoped for out of the shah. The Ottoman ambassador had recently finished neogiating a peace treaty, Ottoman merchants at court were warning that this English “Franke” would ruin their trade. Was the shah being a truly devout ruler, or did he not want to annoy the Ottomans? I did have to modernize the spelling of this source to make it less cumbersome for students to understand it.

Document 3: Jahangir on his father (early 1600s)

In his memoirs, Jahangir describes Akbhar’s empire as a place where “Sunnis and Shias met in one mosque, and Franks and Jews in one church.” There was room, he says, for “the professors of opposite religions,” on the principle that “the Shadow must have the same properties as the Light.”

I was not sure what was meant by that last line until I read a footnote provided by the editor/translator of the source. He wrote that “Kings are regarded as shadows of God.” That means toleration was not just a policy for Akbhar or Jahangir, it was part of what made the emperor godlike. The passing of power from father to son and the legitimacy required for that transition are also an important part of understanding this source.

Document 4: An Englishman’s view of Ottoman toleration (1668)

Paul Rycaut, secretary to the English ambassador in Constantinople, saw the same system Zarfati praised and was not impressed. Christian churches could be repaired, he writes, but no one could “lay a stone in a new place Consecrated to Divine Service,” and the whole arrangement was “rather to afflict and persecute” Christianity “then any grant of favour.”

I hope students will notice that two outsiders describe the same system and reach different conclusions. The next step is to ask why, and at that point they should realize the two accounts are separated by more than two centuries. Historical context helps explain the difference. In 1456, the Ottomans were focused on rebuilding Constantinople as a world city and saw the value of bringing in newcomers, whether by choice or by force. By 1668, the empire was well established and operating in a different context. It simply didn’t need outsiders as much, and it was more settled in its Islamic identity. Rycaut may also be witnessing the effects of the Kadızadeli movement, an Islamic reform movement that pushed Ottoman religious policy toward greater conservatism in these years.

Document 5: The Qing Sacred Edict (1670 and 1724)

Maxim 7 of the Sacred Edict reads “Degrade strange religions, in order to exalt the orthodox doctrine.” The Yongzheng Emperor’s explanation calls Catholicism corrupt but admits the government employs the missionaries because they “understand the mathematics,” and tells “soldiers and people” to stop strange sects as they would “torrents, flames, robbers, and thieves.”

The source illustrates how tolerance is either a tool, or necessary allowance, for some other purpose; in this case mathematical knowledge. The translator of this source also added the interesting preface that the edict was read aloud to soldiers and ordinary people twice a month across the empire. This is neither just an ordinary law nor royal opinion, it is purposeful state messaging. This opens up some great HIPP options for students in their analysis.

Document 6: The return of the jizya (1679)

Khafi Khan, a Mughal official and historian, describes Aurangzeb bringing back the jizya on non-Muslims, a tax Akbar had abolished more than a century earlier. After the change was announced, crowds of Hindus in Delhi blocked the road to the mosque to protest until “an order was given to bring out the elephants,” and “at length they submitted to pay the jizya.” The evidence of protests is a great example of how agency is not limited to rulers or the elite.

Document 7: Akbar’s House of Worship (c. 1600 to 1605)

The last document is a painting from the Akbarnama, the official history of Akbar’s reign. It shows a night debate in the Ibadat Khana, the hall Akbar used for scholars of different faiths, with two Jesuits in dark robes on the left and Akbar raised at the center. In the packet it stands on its own, with only a short context statement. This image is shown near the start of the post. Even though the connection is a little obvious, I wanted to include this so students can corroborate the image with Jahangir’s memoirs of his father’s policies and practices.


Bibliography

Graetz, Heinrich. History of the Jews. Vol. 4, 272–73. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1894. Internet Archive. Link

Jahangir. The Tuzuk-i-Jahangiri; or, Memoirs of Jahangir. Translated by Alexander Rogers. Edited by Henry Beveridge. Vol. 1, 37. London: Royal Asiatic Society, 1909. Link

Kangxi Emperor and Yongzheng Emperor. The Sacred Edict. Translated by William Milne. 2nd ed., 70–73. Shanghai: American Presbyterian Mission Press, 1870. Internet Archive. Link

Khafi Khan. Muntakhabu-l Lubab. In H. M. Elliot and John Dowson, The History of India as Told by Its Own Historians, vol. 7, 296. Translated by John Dowson. London: Trübner, 1877. Link

Morgan, E. Delmar, and C. H. Coote, eds. Early Voyages and Travels to Russia and Persia by Anthony Jenkinson and Other Englishmen. Vol. 1, 145–47. London: Hakluyt Society, 1886. Link

Narsingh. Akbar in the Ibadat Khana. Illustration to the Akbarnama, c. 1600–1605. Chester Beatty Library, Dublin, CBL In 03.263b. Image from World History Encyclopedia, public domain. Link

Rycaut, Paul. The Present State of the Ottoman Empire. Book II, chap. 2, 103. London: John Starkey and Henry Brome, 1668. Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership, University of Michigan. Link


The Links

DBQ Documents

Student Organizer

Teacher Notes

If you appreciated this DBQ and would like to offer monetary support, you can “buy” it from my TPT store.

2 thoughts on “AP World DBQ: Religious Toleration in Land-Based Empires”

  1. CoffeeHouseHistorian: This DBQ looks excellent, but I have a quesiton about the terms you define for the readers. Will that be the case on the actual APWorld exam? Thank you!

    • The vocab and guiding questions are scaffolds I often use with students to help them get used to primary source analysis and habits of historical thinking. The DBQ on the AP exam will not have either of those.

Leave a Reply