Modeling Historical Thinking in Old Shanghai

In his writing, Sam Wineburg identifies several historical thinking skills that function as the basic building blocks of historical interpretation, among them sourcing, close reading, corroboration and contextualization. The skill set is the same for AP history students as it is for professional historians; historians simply use these skills with greater complexity. The beautiful thing is that they can be taught in an hour, but they take years to master.

Every source comes from somewhere. Sourcing is the skill of pausing before you dive into analysis and thinking about who made the source and who they made it for. Tap the brakes before scrutinizing details or jumping to conclusions. This is something a lay reader rarely thinks about. It is unnatural, hence the title of Wineburg’s book, Historical Thinking and Other Unnatural Acts. But it is critical to understanding the meaning of a text and what is happening within it.

I have most often heard the term “close reading” in English classrooms. However, this skill is equally important to historians, because it helps them open up sources and access the insight within them. Close reading is not just reading for comprehension. It is less about what is being said than about how it is being said. Every author makes choices about what to put into a document and how to say it. Some of those choices are conscious and some are not, and understanding them can tell us a lot about what was happening in the past. Sometimes it helps to ask how a source could have looked different. That question is a great way to isolate the details and choices that matter.

Inside a lane house Source

Corroboration is the skill of reading sources together, not in isolation. Sources coexist. They agree and they disagree. Understanding the connections between them is a critical step in building larger interpretations. The past is not monolithic, and understanding its complexity requires seeing how individual pieces fit together. That fit will be neither easy nor neat.

Contextualization is the recognition that every source is a product of a time period, of conditions, of influences beyond even the author of the source. A source’s meaning can change according to its context. Strong interpretations mean recognizing that significance of external factors on what a source says and how it says it.

As I work to teach these skills, I increasingly look for ways to model them for my students. Sometimes I do this better than others. Recently, I have been working with a student on an NHD project about shikumen (石库门), a style of lane house that became popular in Shanghai beginning in the 1860s and combined elements of Chinese and Western architecture. Construction of these houses expanded considerably through the late 19th century and into the 20th century, and that development is connected to a number of social, political, and economic changes within Shanghai.

The student’s research led both of us to the digitized archives of the North-China Herald, an English-language newspaper published in Shanghai beginning in 1850. The archives are full of evidence about life in Shanghai in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. As a current Shanghai resident, I have enjoyed looking through a small fraction of these primary sources, and many of them make for good opportunities to model these foundational skills.


Sourcing

The term “shikumen” is rarely used in the paper, foreign residents often opting for phrases like “native” housing or “Chinese” housing in addition to a handful of other terms. Although the sources I found were published in the North-China Herald, they don’t necessarily represent the newspaper’s opinions. The two letters to the editor I found when exploring foreign-resident views on shikumen have clear authors. Students should consider the specific author, who they are, why they are writing, and what they hope to achieve alongside the reality that the paper is selecting which letters and articles to publish.

In a letter to the editor on March 19th, 1874 (left), a Shanghai resident writing as “Cato” defends foreign owners of Chinese houses. On the surface, this is a resident weighing in on the social problem of the taxation of properties owned by foreigners but rented by locals. Read with the author in mind, it sounds like a property owner defending his investment.

Another letter, from March 14th, 1898 (right), appears after several decades of shikumen development in the city. Here the author complains that the building of Chinese houses is leaving no room for foreigners.

This author signs his name, Alfred B. Rex, which makes him far easier to trace than “Cato.” Rex was the founder of a small trading company that represented Western brands in China. Asking why he resents the spread of lane houses is an important part of interpreting the source. As a foreign merchant, he might worry about rents, land prices, or the character of the neighborhood where he lived and worked.


Contextualization

In February 1911, the North-China Herald printed a flurry of letters from residents and responses from the Shanghai Municipal Council about new by-laws for the building and upkeep of Chinese houses. One of these letters, from February 17th, complains that landlords are being unfairly blamed for a “disinclination” to install rat-proof floors, when the real problem was how the by-laws were enforced.

On its own, a source like this could read as a routine complaint about red tape. However, the source requires context that it does not provide. In 1910, bubonic plague, spread by fleas carried on rats, reached Shanghai. The Council’s inspections and disinfection in Chinese neighborhoods sparked riots, and the Council also turned to building rules to keep rats out of houses. At the same time, a separate pneumonic plague was sweeping through Manchuria and raising alarm across China.

In Shanghai, fear of the plague and its carriers was strong enough to shape how houses were physically built. With that in mind, the letter becomes part of a larger argument over who would bear the cost of a public-health campaign.


Close Reading

In June 1920, the North-China Herald ran two pieces headed “The House Famine.” The first is a leading article (right), the paper’s own editorial voice, which blames landlords for the predicament. The second, in the Notes & Comments section, responds to a landlord’s letter of protest. It gives the landlord’s side a hearing but still concedes that profiteers exist. Two weeks later, a June 26 Notes & Comments piece titled “The Profiteers” turns the blame on tenants, arguing that some are sub-letting their houses at far higher rents than they pay their landlords.

The term “famine” is not neutral. Its connotation suggests a significant disaster. However, another powerful word to notice in a close read is “profiteer.” In the years immediately after WWI, the term carried anger at individuals who got rich from shortages. Within two weeks, the paper aims it first at landlords and then at tenants. More contextualization and corroboration could show whether there is a more significant interpretation down this line of inquiry.


Corroboration

One of the more interesting terms to come out of my reading was “key money.” On June 5, 1920, the paper covered the resolution of a court case over whether a $4,000 payment was a deposit or “key money.” According to the article, a deposit would be refundable, but key money would not. Was this an isolated incident, or a common point of contention between landlords and tenants?

An article from March 1930 explains how the system worked in connection with another court case. An article from December 1935 suggests that tenants could be required to pay key money worth as much as a year’s rent to secure a property. In total, I found 68 issues of the paper that mention key money between 1920 and 1941. This was clearly not an isolated incident but a recurring practice and a persistent source of conflict in Shanghai. Its depth and scale only become visible when you consider multiple sources published across two decades.

These sources all come from the same newspaper, though. Stronger corroboration would come from sources with different perspectives, such as Chinese-language newspapers, which report key money for a single shikumen reaching 4,000 yuan by 1940.


None of these skills works alone. Sourcing told me who was writing, close reading showed me how they chose their words, contextualization explained why those words mattered at the time, and corroboration showed whether a single story was part of a larger pattern. In practice, I moved back and forth between them constantly, and each one raised questions the others had to answer.

Working through these sources also revealed what the North-China Herald can’t tell us. Almost every voice in these pages belongs to a property owner, a foreign resident, or the Municipal Council. The people who actually lived in the lane houses rarely speak for themselves. These skills can’t add voices that aren’t in the archive, but they can show us whose voices are missing and point us toward where to look for them next.

And that is another valuable skill to model for students. Historical thinking isn’t about finding the right source and pulling out the answer, it’s about asking better questions of every source you find.

Leave a Reply